A Bloomington veteran passed away in August 2016. He was rated by the VA as 60% service connected disabled for ischemic heart disease but the only cause of death listed on his death certificate was aspiration pneumonia. The Monroe County (Indiana) Veterans Service Officer assisted the widow in filing for VA Dependency Indemnity Compensation (DIC) as a service connected death. The VA Pension Center denied the DIC claim on 14 November “because the evidence does not show that the cause of death was related to military service.”
I had known the veteran and his wife for several years. She called regarding the VA denial. During our conversation she mentioned the attending nurse said, “His heart stopped. We probably could have brought him back, but he had a ‘do not resuscitate’.” I visited the widow, got the names and contact information for the medical people who were familiar with his heart condition and the circumstances surrounding his passing, and she and I visited their office manager. (Having the widow with me avoided HIPAA privacy protection problems.) Within fifteen minutes we agreed that they would provide a medical statement directly to the VA that the veteran’s ischemic heart disease contributed to his passing.
I wrote a letter to the VA Pension Center requesting reconsideration of their denial on the basis of the medical statement. I attached a copy of the statement, a copy of the veteran’s 60% VA rating for ischemic heart disease, included a list of the names and contact information for several of the cardiology staff who were also willing to support the ‘contributed to’ conclusion, and a VA Form 21-22a designating me as her representative.
The first indication the widow and I had that the request had been successful was a Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS) letter to her in February 2017. She had been drawing $567 a month Survivors Benefit Plan (SBP) because her military retiree husband had paid SBP premiums for years via deduction from his retired pay. The DFAS letter said her SBP was terminated retroactively to September and she owed all the money back! I told her to not worry about the letter because the only reason for stoppage was that DIC and SBP still have a full offset, the inane “widow’s tax” which punishes surviving spouses whose retiree passed away due to service connected causes. They can’t draw both, usually just the bigger of the two. The VA must have decided in her favor but could not pay her the full, non-taxable DIC until the SBP was stopped.
On 20 March 2017 I received my ‘representative’s copy’ of her official award of DIC notice from the VA. She will draw $1,257.95 a month DIC from 1 December 2016 onward and $1,254.19 a month, the previous rate, from 1 September 2016 through 30 November 2016 – a bit over $7,540 retroactive pay.
I called the VA first in pursuit of how the widow needed to apply for Special Survivor Indemnity Allowance (SSIA). The VA did not know. I then called DFAS. SSIA is a $310.00 monthly special allowance by which Congress apologized for the full offset between SBP and DIC. They were too cheap to repeal the offset, even though DIC is earned for the surviving spouse by the sacrifice of the veteran who by his or her service connected death gave his life for his country, and SBP is fully paid for (the fund has excess money, as a matter of fact) by the retiree through deduction of the premiums. DFAS told me there is no SSIA application form or procedure, the SSIA is automatic following a full audit of the widow’s DFAS account which takes three to four months. In our widow’s case, the audit will determine how much of the SBP premium money will be refunded to her, probably a reduced amount in lieu of her repaying the SBP paid.
She loses the SBP $567 per month. She gains the DIC $1,257.95 per month with about $7,540 back pay. (Not that she’s thinking of it now, but since she’s over fifty-seven years old she keeps the DIC even if she remarries.) She’ll pick up the SSIA $310 per month with $1,860 back pay and the SBP premium money refund around June or July. The SBP premium refund is a one-time settlement, I’m guessing of several thousand dollars. Because the veteran’s passing is now considered by the VA as service connected she will receive an additional amount for his burial/funeral expenses beyond the $1,047.00 ‘regular’ amount already paid, a one-time supplemental payment of $953.00.
I called the widow. She had not read the VA letter. I told her about it. She started to cry. She had sold some items from her home to buy food. I hung up because I did not want her to hear me crying.
“Thank you” Easter Bunny Bouquet from the widow. She’d received her DIC retroactive benefits. I’ll bet this cost more than the letter and postage to the VA.
The law supporting the SSIA $310 per month expires on 30 September 2017. When SSIA was created Congress intended the SSIA dollar amount to increase each time a new SSIA law was passed until the DIC-SBP offset was finally overcome. Without Congressional action, our widow and all other surviving spouses eligible for SBP and DIC will lose their SSIA this October.
11 thoughts on “SBP, DIC, SSIA, and Reconsideration”
I have created a letter to send to our elected officials to ensure that this situation is rectified – extend the SSIA and make it more for the future or make sure that the widow’s tax is removed and all survivors are provided what their veterans earned.
You are a good man John. Than you for all you do.
This widow was very fortunate to know you. You have done so much for her. Thank you for your kindness. The way things are going with the actual government, I guess we’ll lose the SSIA. We’ll see. I do receive the DIC, but what are my “VA” benefits? Their website is so confusing, their staff are not very knowledgeable. I’ve been getting so many different answers. My husband was rated 100% disabled, and was retired from the Army. I would like to hear from you.
I would love to speak with you about your situation. Please call me at home 812 336 5574 or on my cell phone 812 219 8235 or email at email@example.com.
I received a letter from dfas- my ssia is terminated …
Ms. Green, would you please tell me via email to firstname.lastname@example.org the whole story?
How can we get the monthly $310.00 ssia reinstated…. May, 2018 is due to be the last payment.
Who should we call or email?
Carolyn S. Morgan
It was extended indefinitely and – if my poor memory serves – will have “cost of living” increases. ‘Still a poor substitute for eliminating the offset.
John, this is great news! I was preparing myself mentally to live with $310.00 less in my budget. When was this decided? How did you find out? I’ve been looking throughout the net for an answer. I should know better, and come to you for them 🙂 Thank you for everything you do for the Veteran family.
EDIT! When I searched just now for confirmation I could not find anything past the SSIA extension until May 2018. I hope my old memory cells were correct, but I shur cain’t find it now.
I AM GETTING DIC IT IS GREATER THAN SBP! THEY HAVE NOT STOPPED THE SBP SO I WENT TO DAV WHO HELPED ME GET DIC AND TOLD THEM SINCE THEY HAVE MY POA I NEEDED THEM TO FIND OUT WHY DFAS IS STILL SENDING SBP. I DO NOT WANT TO END UP OWING THE DFAS BECAUSE SOMEONE IS NOT DOING THEIR JOB! DAV TOLD ME I WAS TO GET BOTH AND I HAVE CALLED VA, DFAS SEVERAL TIMES AND GET NO HELP, I HAVE BEEN GETTING DIC AND SBP BOTH FOR 32 MONTHS! HELP!
Ms Graham, I’m emailing you now.